“Better late than never.” “The bigger they are, the harder
they fall.” “Fits like a glove.” “Not the brightest bulb in the box.” Clichés
are a vital part of our language and our culture and they often play a key role
in movies. Many films base their story lines off of typical clichés because
people can relate to them. Garry Marshall’s 2010 star-studded film Valentine’s
Day played to the cliché “true love will always prevail” but also subliminally
communicated a problematic message of “being single is bad.”
The cliché that love always wins and true love will always
find its way is communicated overtly in the overall plot of the film. This
movie is unique in that it follows six or more different story lines as it
documents all the characters’ issues on Valentine’s Day. One character deals
with finding out her boyfriend is actually married, another struggles with his
sexuality, while yet another deals with being a senior in college and
knowing she will be far away from her boyfriend in a few months as they leave
for college. Each character has their own unique struggles with relationships,
but in the end they all find love. The first woman gets revenge on her married
boyfriend and realizes she’s in love with her best friend, the second meets a
cute man, and the third just learns to celebrate her happiness with her
boyfriend and live for today. This cheesy and unmistakable message that “love
will triumph” is very effective in this film as it relies on emotional
arguments. As Andrea Lunsford describes in Everything’s
An Argument, the scenes of each character finding their happiness and
discovering love use pathos to “hit precisely the right note” in the heart of
the viewer (Lunsford 40). This use of pathos truly makes the movie-goer feel the thesis of love and happiness.
While the movie is a heart-lifting story of true love, it
also sends mixed messages of love being the only place to find satisfaction and
of singleness being embarassing.
This is communicated when Bradley Cooper explains that he
doesn’t like heart shaped candy because “it reminds [him] that this is
Valentine’s Day and [he] is newly single” (Valentine’s
Day film). His tone of embarrassment and disdain over being recently single
communicates the idea that it is something to be ashamed of. Also a particular
subplot that plays well into this problematic theme is the one of Jessica
Biel’s character. She is an extremely hardworking career woman that is so
consumed by her work that she answers phone calls while running on the
treadmill in her office. She is a single woman and she does not hide her
anguish over the fact that she is single on Valentine’s Day. She even despairs,
“I just want to know if in fact I am the only person on the whole freaking
planet who is completely and 100% alone on Valentine’s Day” (Valentine’s Day film). She is completely
miserable the whole movie and the only time we see her happy is in the end in
which she ends up with a man. This subplot reflects nicely what Giannetti
describes in his Understanding Movies
as a “women’s picture – emphasizing a female star and focusing on typical
female concerns such as getting (or holding on to) a man” (Giannetti 430). Just as the cliche message played on pathos, this problematic message relies on the argument of ethos. Unfortunately, Bradley Cooper and Jessica Biel's characters both seem to define themselves based on their relationship status. Biel is a powerful career woman that clearly has made a great living for herself, but she feel worthless because she doesn't have a man in her life. This idea of identity shows that the ethos of these characters is defined by their love lives, which is frankly horrendous!
I believe the intended audience for this film was sixteen to
thirty year-old women. Although men can definitely watch the film and not be
completely miserable (take their girls on an actual Valentine’s Day date?), the
messages were more intended for their female counterparts. Unfortunately, this
means that the targeted viewers are not just enjoying a happy love story; they
are subliminally receiving the message that they cannot be happy without a man
in their lives and that being single is something to be ashamed of.
For it’s subliminal message of women needing men (and my
belief that women can just be as powerful without a man), I give this film a
mere two bags of buttery popcorn.