Jennifer Siebel Newsom released her
documentary, Miss Representation, in
January of 2011 at the Sundance Film Festival. The documentary is solely based
on the gender injustices that occur in the media. Miss Representation gained a
lot of praise and also sprouted some controversy, as well as the beginning of the
Representation Project. The Representation project, “is a movement that uses
film and media content to expose injustices created by gender stereotypes and
to shift people’s consciousness towards change (therepresentationproject.org).”
This is an amazing movement, in that it really shows and teaches people about
what goes on in the media and how our society has used it to brainwash people
about gender roles.
The start of this movement also led to the creation of the
“Representation Test.” According to the Representation Project website, this
test is a “media literacy tool to spark learning and conversation around
representation in film, and to encourage more overall diversity on screen and
behind-the-scenes in Hollywood. (therepresentation.org)” After looking over the
test, I find the components very interesting only because these are topics that
I just never really paid attention to. There are 5 categories and a Bonus Points category. These
categories consist of Women; Men; Race, Ethnicity, Culture; LGBT People; and
People with Disabilities.
For our final blog, our assignment was to pick any movie,
use the representation test, see how it rates on the scale and then explain our
findings. Now, I chose one of my all time favorite movies that I have always
dreamed of being the main characters: Lara
Croft: Tomb Raider. You would think that this film was going to fail
terribly, but you will be surprised to know that it actually scored 9 out of 27 points/ a
B! That’s pretty incredible knowing this is an intense action movie based off
of a gruesomely violent video game. I thought the best way to break this down
would be to just go by category...
But first, just a little background about the movie just in
case you have not seen it. Like I said, it’s based off the famously infamous
video game about a bad-ass female archeologist, Lara Croft. She is a tomb raider
that enjoys collecting ancient artifacts from places of ruin in history. She is
amazingly skilled in weaponry and fighting, she also has plenty of knowledge of
different cultures and languages. Basically, she is kind of a bad-ass. In the
movie, she is sent on a mission by her late father to stop an Illuminati group
from gaining power due to an astronomical alignment and the finding of an
ancient device that can control time. There is a lot of fighting, but there is
a good ending to the movie and good triumphed over evil- Lara Croft saved the
day!
Women
The movie gained extra points on the fact that the
protagonist of the movie is indeed a woman. Unfortunately, there is not
diversity of women in the movie. Based on the Representation Test, the movie
lacked women of color, diverse body types, and age. The movie also did not pass
the Bechdel Test; it did not even pass the first question of the BT. There is
only one female character in this movie. Tomb Raider does, in fact, represent
Croft as more than an “object for the male gaze.” Croft speaks so
intelligently, there is nothing that degrades her or makes her seem like a
ditzy bimbo. While she does wear tight clothing, she never shows too much skin. There is
no cleavage with her tank top, she wears long pants, and the most
skin she shows are her arms; with the exception of the movie poster that
displays Croft in spandex shorts but she does not wear those shorts throughout
the movie. Lara
Croft: Tomb Raider is one of the highest grossing video game movies with a
female protagonist! (forbes.com)
Which I really liked to see because the audience is not focusing on
her sex appeal; they are mainly focusing on her kicking the bad guy’s ass. Just
a little side note- according to Forbes,
Men
Tomb Raider does not show men in stereotypical ways. The
male characters all have different body types; there is no body type that gains
more praise or scrutiny than another. We have Croft’s friend and weapon
creator, Bryce who is an average looking guy.
There is also Alex West, Croft's
ex-love interest (but not really), he is a fit guy but does not flaunt off his
body. There is one scene of him in the shower and Croft torments with him, but
there is no sexual innuendo being used. Now, this is a violent movie filled
with guns and fighting; however, the movie does not glorify violent. I could
see someone trying to argue this, which I may be wrong. This is just how I
viewed the movie. It was the bad guys that were majorly violent, wanting to kill Croft and anyone that stood in their way. Notice how I said “bad
guys?” They are the ones that need to be stopped. There is nothing about men
being violent towards women just because. However, at the end the leader of the
bad guys does get into a fistfight with Croft. Though Croft does take a
beating, because he is a man, she does overcome him and gives him even more of
a beating. Croft won in a fight against a man. Says a lot about the fact that
women can overcome anything. When it came down to deciding if the movie had
“one or more men of color, in speaking roles, who are NOT reduced to racial
stereotypes,” I did have a little difficulty. There are monks from Cambodia in
the film with speaking roles; there is no stereotyping at all, because that is
their culture. Which is exactly why I gave the movie an extra point and goes
further into the next category.
Race, Ethnicity, Culture
The movie’s events take place in different places around the
world: Great Britain, Venice, Cambodia, and Siberia. Obviously these are
different cultures, and the movie did a good job at not having any stereotypes
nor picking the wrong actors to portray these characters.
Unfortunately, Tomb Raider does not have characters of LGBT
people or people with disabilities. Nor is it written or directed by an LGBT or
person of disability. I do not think the reason is anything against these
people at all. Simply that this was not that kind of story line.
Tomb Raider did gain a “bonus point”, surprisingly
enough, it was co-written by a woman! Sara Cooper and Mark Werb wrote the
storyline for the movie (imdb.com). I really found this interesting because, I
had no clue a woman helped write this movie. This really proves that even women
can be involved with the making of an action movie.
After totaling the score, Tomb Raider got a B on the
Representation Test. I’m surprised because I thought this would score lower due
to the fact that it is an action movie with only one female character. But
since, Croft is so skilled and knowledgeable, I feel that she is a good role
model for girls. She truly shows that any woman can do what she does if they
have the strong will to make it happen. I do believe the scoring system is fair
because it really does open your eyes to see what these movies have in between
the lines. You can learn a lot about a movie by scoring it with this test. It
really aides the movement in showing what goes on behind-the-scenes, and people
are able to see that a movie can be degrading or very stereotypical. I praise
this movement, and can’t wait to see what comes of it in years ahead.
No comments:
Post a Comment